Trading Pins
Ordering Pins
Types of Pins
Custom Cooperstown Pins








Custom Cooperstown pins are one of the biggest parts of the week at Dreams Park and All-Star Village. Teams from across the country trade pins with each other, and the pins that get the most attention are almost never the plain traditional ones. We make custom Cooperstown pins for thousands of teams every year. Most of them are soft enamel, with photoscreen as the faster alternative when timing is tight.
At Cooperstown the goal is usually simple: have pins that other kids actually want. A traditional ball-field, crossed-bats, or numbered-baseball design still has a place if your team wants one, but those alone tend to stay in the bag. The pins that move are the ones that feel rare, limited, or unexpected. Pop-culture twists, candy, cartoons, movie references, and bold original characters all trade better than the classic team-logo look most teams used a decade ago.
Request Your Free DesignWhat Style of Custom Cooperstown Pins Works Best?
Soft enamel remains the clear favorite, with hard UV print often used to create small details. Roughly 85-90% of the custom Cooperstown pins we produce are soft enamel (sometimes called die-struck with color). The textured surface feels substantial in hand and holds up well over time. Photoscreen pins are the usual second choice when a team needs full-color detail or a shorter production window. Soft enamel takes longer, so teams that want it typically order in the off-season.
You can review the differences on our photoscreen vs. soft enamel comparison page if you are still deciding.
Design Trends: Traditional Team Pins vs. Pins That Actually Trade
Traditional team pins still have a place and most coaches still order a set of them. The problem is that a full order of crossed bats, jersey numbers, and ball fields does not trade well anymore. Players see hundreds of nearly identical designs in a single session. Those pins often come home with the team.
The custom Cooperstown pins that disappear fast tend to share a few traits:
- They feel limited or special rather than generic
- They have a pop-culture, snack, cartoon, or humor angle
- They are large enough to notice (usually 2.50"-3.00")
- They are designed to be wanted by other kids, not just to represent the team
A good approach for many teams is a mix: a solid team pin with a great design for the team who want one, plus at least one wilder limited-edition design that becomes the pin other teams hunt for. Rarity & design substance drive trading. A five-design order comprised of nothing but limited quantity rare design themes will cost more, but will make your players trading superstars at the park. No one wants to lug home four or five hundred untraded team pins. Think outside the box... some of the best traders don't even look like baseball pins! Sibling pins, coach pins, and parent pins are also common. Those can be pure fun and do not always need the team name.
Popular Design Directions for Custom Cooperstown Pins
Designs that consistently trade well include:
- Candy and snack themes - candy bars, soda cans, ice cream, pizza, donuts
- Pop-culture and meme references with a light baseball twist
- Popular sports figures - they don't even need to be baseball players
- Cartoon or exaggerated versions of the team mascot
- Baseball-card style layouts that feature a player
- Puns on the team name, hometown, or mascot
- Moving elements such as danglers, spinners, or sliders once the core design is strong
The team name, colors, and year can still appear. They just should not be the entire concept. A clear name plus a creative idea usually outperforms a plain baseball pin.
Recommended Size for Custom Cooperstown Pins
Size is one of the most common mistakes. Small pins are frequently passed over when kids are sorting trades. The sizes that trade best are typically 2.00" to 2.50". A larger pin with a strong design almost always outperforms a smaller pin loaded with extras.
Get the size right first. Then add attachments or special finishes if the budget allows. Our size comparison page shows the visual difference.
How Many Custom Cooperstown Pins Do Teams Usually Order?
These are some of the largest trading-pin orders we handle. Dreams Park runs 104 teams per session. All-Star Village averages around 60. An 11- or 12-player team that wants each player to have enough pins to trade with most of the other teams will often land in the 1,000-1,200 pin range for Dreams Park, plus extras for coaches, siblings, and parents.
Many families order separate sibling pins that are purely fun and do not carry the team name. Coach and parent pins are also popular.
Cooperstown Pin Ordering Guide
Still need help figuring out how many pins to order, what size to pick, or when to start? The Cooperstown Pin Ordering Guide walks teams through the whole plan for Dreams Park, All Star Village, and TBR Cooperstown. Our team pin Order Estimator starts at a 100-pin player baseline and lets you add coaches, siblings, parents, and a reserve. It covers which sizes trade best and why imaginative, rare designs often out-trade traditional baseball pins.
Cooperstown Pin Ordering GuideWhen to Order
Soft enamel custom Cooperstown pins take longer to produce than photoscreen. Teams that want soft enamel and a relaxed design process usually order in the fall or early winter. Waiting until spring often forces a switch to photoscreen or a rush fee. Starting early also gives more time to refine a creative design.
Frequently Asked Questions About Custom Cooperstown Pins
What style of custom Cooperstown pins should we order?
Soft enamel is the most popular choice by a wide margin. About 85-90% of the Cooperstown pins we make are soft enamel. Photoscreen is the practical backup when a team needs full color or a faster turnaround. Order soft enamel early if that is your preference.
Are traditional team pins still worth ordering?
They can still have a place, but a full order of classic ball-field, crossed-bats, or numbered-baseball designs does not trade the way it once did. Most teams now mix a traditional pin with at least one more creative, limited-edition design that other kids actually want. The traditional pin represents the team; the creative pin gets traded.
What design ideas trade best at Cooperstown?
Pins with pop-culture flair, snack or candy themes, cartoon characters, humor, or unexpected concepts trade faster than plain baseball designs. Rare or limited-edition sets also perform well because they feel special. A bold idea with the team name readable somewhere on the pin usually outperforms a standard team logo pin.
Do teams order pins for siblings, coaches, and parents?
Yes. Sibling pins are very common and often do not include the team name at all. Coach pins and parent pins are also popular. These can be pure fun designs since the main goal for those groups is usually trading and collecting rather than representing the team on the field.
What size works best for custom Cooperstown pins?
Most successful trading pins are 2.00" to 2.50". Smaller pins are frequently overlooked. Prioritize size first, then add extras such as danglers or special finishes if the budget allows. A larger pin with a strong design trades better than a small pin with bling.
How many custom Cooperstown pins do we need?
Enough for each player to trade with other teams, plus extras for coaches, siblings, and parents. An 11-player team at Dreams Park (104 teams) often needs around 1,200 pins. All-Star Village orders are usually smaller. Use the ordering guide estimator for a more precise number.
When should we place our order?
For soft enamel, the earlier the better. Fall, winter & early spring orders give the most flexibility on design and production. Summer orders are still possible but often require photoscreen or a rush fee.
Request Your Free Design
